Why heat treatment sometimes fails

Drywood termites are notorious for their ability to wreak havoc on wooden structures, and homeowners often search for effective methods to eradicate them. One popular approach is heat treatment, which involves raising the temperature of the infested area to levels that can kill termites. However, this method is not infallible. Recent developments in California have brought to light the limitations and failures of heat treatment, leading to growing concerns about its effectiveness as a standalone solution.

Heat treatment aims to raise the temperature of wood to a lethal level for termites, typically around 150°F (65°C). This is achieved by using specialized heaters placed in strategic locations such as attics, crawl spaces, and inside the infested home. The theory is straightforward: once the core wood reaches the required temperature for a sustained period, the termites will succumb to the heat.

Despite its seemingly straightforward application, several factors contribute to the failure of heat treatment for drywood termites:

1. Inadequate Heat Distribution: One of the most significant challenges with heat treatment is ensuring that the heat penetrates evenly throughout the entire structure, particularly in complex spaces like attics or multi-unit dwellings such as condos and apartments. If there are areas of the house where heat cannot effectively reach, cold spots can arise, leaving pockets of termites alive and well.

2. Heat Leakage and Improper Seals: Achieving and maintaining the required temperature is further complicated by potential heat loss. Open doors, windows, and other areas of poor sealing can allow heat to escape, reducing the overall effectiveness of the treatment. Proper sealing is crucial, but it’s often not achievable in practice, especially in older buildings with various entry points.

3. Wood Density: Different wood types and densities can exhibit varying thermal conductivity. Dense or thicker woods may not reach the necessary temperatures throughout their core, even if the outer surfaces are sufficiently heated. This can create a situation where the outer layer of wood is hot enough to kill termites, but the inner core remains unaffected.

4. Evolving Termite Behavior: Recent studies have indicated that some termite species may exhibit behavioral adaptations to withstand temperatures that would typically be lethal. For instance, certain colonies may create tunnels or retreat to cooler areas, thereby avoiding exposure to high temperatures.

Until recently, heat treatment was approved by the Structural Pest Control Board in California as a method capable of achieving a 100% success rate in controlling drywood termites. However, the rise in treatment failures has prompted a re-evaluation of its effectiveness and led to the withdrawal of this approval. Homeowners and pest control experts alike are now increasingly recognizing that heat treatment alone may not be a reliable solution.

Given the limitations of heat treatment, structural fumigation has emerged as a more reliable method for termite elimination. Fumigation involves sealing the entire structure and introducing a gas that penetrates all wood materials, effectively killing termites in every nook and cranny.

While fumigation requires more logistical planning and may necessitate the temporary relocation of residents, its effectiveness in ensuring complete eradication of drywood termites is unmatched. It addresses the problems of heat leakage and improper distribution, providing homeowners with greater peace of mind.

While heat treatment may seem like a convenient option for tackling drywood termites, its inherent challenges can lead to shortcomings in actual practice.